Last night we went to a BYOB French bistro,
Yo In Yo Out, in East Harlem (
Lex bw 101st and 102
nd). Since the restaurant opened in February, 2009 it has been getting rave reviews on
Yelp! for it's friendly owners, yummy food, casual atmosphere and BYOB status. I was really excited to test out a new restaurant, especially a BYOB.
The atmosphere was very relaxed and the staff welcoming. The hostess/waitress greeted and sat us as soon as we walked in. They obliged opening one of the two floor-to-ceiling windows at the front of the restaurant to let in some much needed cool air. The waitress was French and very friendly, indulging the minimal French our table mustered up. The bathroom was also extremely clean, which is a huge THUMBS UP! in my book.
To start we ordered
Les Fromages- "
Artisinal imported cheese served with fresh seasonal fruits and fig coulis" and
Les Charcuteries- "Imported cold meats and pates served with selection of
mustards and
cornichons." The cheese and meat selection were good, but there were no seasonal fruits or pates to be seen! I suppose I can't be too critical though as the menu notes the dishes are made up of "Chef
Yo's Weekly Market Selection." R had the Peach Champagne soup to start. It was a cold soup that looked beautiful, but reminded me of canned peaches rather then fresh. I definitely want to try to make a version of this soup, maybe with fresh mint.
While there were rave reviews about the crepes I decided to order the
Truffle Croque Madame- "Open faced brioche with truffle
bechamel,
jambon blanc and melted
gruyere," served with an egg sunny side up. I absolutely love
Croque Madame's- basically is is a ham and
gruyere (
Swiss like cheese) grilled cheese, but the thick bread is topped with a
bechamel sauce and a sunny side up egg (
Croque Monsieur is no egg). It is an extremely rich and luscious meal, and I've enjoyed plenty around NYC. This wasn't the best
Croque Madame I've ever had, it was decent, but a little uninspired considering the yum ingredients you are working with! Regardless, I definitely ate the whole thing and was satisfied.
We also ordered the
Gratin Dauphinois (Potato Gratin) and the
Gratin de Coquillettes (Mac and Cheese). These were very similar dishes with a heavy cheese/cream sauce that was tasty but masked the contents of the dish. R's sister ordered a shrimp
penne in a basil tomato sauce. The pasta was a really overcooked but it the flavors were right.
It's paining me to be critical of this restaurant because it I had a
really nice time, and the food was definitely not awful. The problem was that my
expectations were set so high due to the RAVE reviews online....
"I LOVE THIS PLACE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I love crepes.
I love overly friendly services.
I love the decor. So
frenchy. So open. Literally, no windows, with the wind blowing gently into this dainty little place.
This place makes me feel high.
It made me want to bring all my posse here. And then get a new posse and bring THEM here." (
Elsie W. Jamaica, NY, Yelp! Review)
All in all, Yo In Yo Out has decent food but the real experience is it's extremely pleasant (and don't forget BYOB!) atmosphere.